The Benefits Committee will be hosting a live Q&A Webinar for pastors and pension participants on Monday, March 23rd at 4:00 pm ET. This webinar will be recorded and made available on this page. Prior to the webinar, please consider sending in your question to ensure there is time to address all questions in the hour we have allotted through the form here by March 16:
Dear Superintendents, Pastors, and Leaders:
As you likely have heard, there are some significant changes coming to the FMCUSA pension plan. Please know, these decisions were not made lightly. Careful and prayerful consideration, time, and effort have been put into the discussions surrounding these changes that will impact our current and future pension plan participants.
To help provide some information, we have put together this Q&A for you to review, which will hopefully provide some clarity on the upcoming changes and how they will impact you. As always, the FMCUSA Human Resources office, along with the members of the Benefits Committee, stand ready to field your questions and concerns.
In Christ,
The Benefits Committee of the FMCUSA Board of Administration:
Charles Toy, chair, Greg Delamarter, Michael Forney, Kirk Hoffman, John Lane, Darrel Riley, Melinda Vokal and Dale Woods II.
Dear Pension Participants,
This coming Monday, the 23rd of March at 4:00 PM Eastern Time, a Zoom Webinar will be hosted for all pension participants and recipients regarding the freeze of the pension, which is to come when it reaches full funding of 107%.
There are two important things for you to note regarding this webinar:
- You need to register to attend. Please click the following link to register for the webinar: https://us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_Y478RTwGTGW0s6tQWSsmxQ. Once you have registered, you will receive the link to the webinar. Only those registered may attend.
- Please read the attached documents. Our actuaries at Nyhart have prepared two detailed documents for you to become familiar with prior to the webinar. They contain vital information about the type of plan the FMCUSA offers and how to calculate your estimated lump sum payout when the freeze occurs. Please read document 1 first, and review document 2 second.
Also, remember, to submit questions for the panelists, please fill out the following form at this link:
We look forward to your attendance at the webinar.
On behalf of HR and the Benefits Committee,
Brett Heintzman
Director of Communications
Did the Board of Administration vote to freeze the pension?
-
- Yes, the denominational BOA voted to authorize the Benefits Committee to freeze the pension when it reaches 107% funded.
- Once the pension freezes, there will be no change for those receiving a pension benefit at that time. Individuals who have not started receiving their pension as of the freeze will be given a lump sum payment that can be rolled over to their own individual retirement account or to a 403(b) plan (more details are given below).
What does it mean to “freeze” the pension?
“Freezing” the pension means that people who are not yet retired or not receiving their pension will receive a lump sum payment of the current present value of their accrued benefit at the time of the freeze. People who are retired will continue to receive their benefits with no change. At the time of the freeze no new entrants will be allowed, no employer contributions will be collected, and no new benefits will accrue.
Why are we freezing the pension after reaching 107% funded?
-
- We believe it is missional to do so. Many local churches, pastors and superintendents have expressed that the current pension plan is too costly and is taking resources away from mission. For example, some churches discourage people from becoming ordained due to the cost of the pension.
- Increasingly, younger pastors do not see the pension as a benefit as they prefer more mobility with their retirement that will move with them when and where they serve. Ultimately, we believe that local churches can contribute to a qualified retirement account for pastors that will cost the church less while providing similar or better benefits for the pastors.
- It is expected that freezing the plan after reaching 107% funded will allow the plan to pay full lump sums to active and terminated vested participants and leave the remaining retiree plan with a high likelihood of remaining sufficiently funded to make all benefit payments.
How did we arrive at this decision and who has the authority to freeze the pension?
The Book of Discipline names our Trustees as having authority over the pension plan to enact the freeze and voted to do so at their October 2025 meeting. Additionally, for many years, the FMCUSA has been in conversation with our Benefits Committee, superintendents, and pastors about the need for our churches to provide quality retirement options for their pastors at a reduced cost.
When will the pension “freeze”?
When the pension reaches a funding level of 107%. Actuaries estimate that this will occur between 2031-2033 under the current plan assumptions; however, the actual timing may vary based on future market conditions.
What does our church do in the meantime? Do we continue to contribute to the pension?
Until the plan is frozen, it remains in effect with no changes to the plan requirements or operation. Participation in the plan remains mandatory and is necessary to reach 107% funded as quickly as possible.
What happens to people who are not yet vested?
All active participants will be vested automatically at the time of the freeze.
I’m currently retired and receiving funds from the pension. Will I continue to receive my monthly payment?
-
- Yes. Pension payments will continue as they have been.
- Participants currently receiving a monthly benefit will not have an option for a lump sum.
I am in the pension. What if I am not yet retired at the time of the freeze?
All active plan participants who are not yet retired will receive a lump sum payment of the present value of their accrued benefit. Terminated participants with a vested benefit will be included.
How will I receive my funds if I’m receiving the lump sum?
Typically, the options available to you would be to either receive a check for the lump sum or to have it directly rolled over into a retirement account of your choosing that is already established. For information about tax implications and other questions you may have, please consult our friends at FM Financial.
Will the FMCUSA recommend any options for 403(b)s?
-
- Yes, FM Financial, the financial services ministry of the FMCUSA, stands ready to enroll people in 403(b)s to continue or begin their retirement savings. The BOA will mandate that churches make contributions to a pastor’s retirement at a specified minimum level yet to be decided.
- Please note that any lump sum can be rolled over to a 403(b), so the lump sum will not be immediately taxable. It would be immediately taxable if not rolled over to a qualified retirement account.
When will I receive further communications?
Information will be sent out to all parties affected by the changes to the plan as it becomes available, and at regular intervals.
How will I know when the plan freezes?
Regular communications will show current funding percentage and an updated timeline for the expected freeze. As soon as it happens, additional communications will be sent.
